SD cards - Sandisk Extreme III SD or SDHC

Mark · 12-06-2008, 14:22

Which is the fastest - Sandisk Extreme III SD or Extreme III SDHC?

The reason I'm asking is in the past I've bought other brand SDHC Class 6 cards in the hope they'd keep up with my camera and they simply don't (they're fine for normal stuff but no good for continuous shooting). Indeed the only cards I've found that can keep up are my old SD Extreme III cards.

If the SDHC equivalents are sure to be as fast as the SD ones in my S3 IS, then I'm game as they work out slightly cheaper for the total capacity, but if not, I'd rather not waste any more money on cards that promise much and fall flat on delivery.

SCM · 12-06-2008, 14:45

http://uk.sandisk.com/Products/Catal...and_Video.aspx

Lists all the card types and explains the differences between the 2 Mark, might give you more info there to make your mind up on which to go for.

SCM

Mark · 12-06-2008, 14:50

Good info but doesn't really say much about the differences between SD and SDHC, and unfortunately for my camera it's just plain wrong (it says my camera only works up to 2GB but I've had 8GB cards in there).

SCM · 12-06-2008, 14:57

I know keeping up to date with what actually works in your camera can be a pain

From what i read re the SDHC they are more for modern cameras and might not work on earlier ranges of cameras. As you said though hard to know for sure from the site.

You could maybe ask the question on Talk Photography web page to see if anyone is using the SDHC in the camera or not. Might be more knowledgable people there to find out from.

SCM

Mark · 12-06-2008, 15:35

The problem isn't whether SDHC works (it does), it's whether the card will be fast enough to compete with my existing SD cards (none of the three SDHC cards I already have are fast enough, but none of them are Sandisk).

Mark · 21-06-2008, 21:21

It works. \o/

Moral of this story - if you want a fast SD or SDHC card, avoid the chaff.

12-06-2008, 14:22	#1
Mark Screaming Orgasm Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Newbury Posts: 15,194	SD cards - Sandisk Extreme III SD or SDHC Which is the fastest - Sandisk Extreme III SD or Extreme III SDHC? The reason I'm asking is in the past I've bought other brand SDHC Class 6 cards in the hope they'd keep up with my camera and they simply don't (they're fine for normal stuff but no good for continuous shooting). Indeed the only cards I've found that can keep up are my old SD Extreme III cards. If the SDHC equivalents are sure to be as fast as the SD ones in my S3 IS, then I'm game as they work out slightly cheaper for the total capacity, but if not, I'd rather not waste any more money on cards that promise much and fall flat on delivery.

12-06-2008, 14:45	#2
SCM As endorsed by Mr Black Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Hell/Scotland take your pick Posts: 443	http://uk.sandisk.com/Products/Catal...and_Video.aspx Lists all the card types and explains the differences between the 2 Mark, might give you more info there to make your mind up on which to go for. SCM __________________ The sun is rising The screams have gone Too many have fallen Few still stand tall Is this the ending of what we've begun? Will we remember what we've done wrong?

12-06-2008, 14:57	#4
SCM As endorsed by Mr Black Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Hell/Scotland take your pick Posts: 443	I know keeping up to date with what actually works in your camera can be a pain From what i read re the SDHC they are more for modern cameras and might not work on earlier ranges of cameras. As you said though hard to know for sure from the site. You could maybe ask the question on Talk Photography web page to see if anyone is using the SDHC in the camera or not. Might be more knowledgable people there to find out from. SCM __________________ The sun is rising The screams have gone Too many have fallen Few still stand tall Is this the ending of what we've begun? Will we remember what we've done wrong?

12-06-2008, 14:50	#3
Mark Screaming Orgasm Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Newbury Posts: 15,194	Good info but doesn't really say much about the differences between SD and SDHC, and unfortunately for my camera it's just plain wrong (it says my camera only works up to 2GB but I've had 8GB cards in there).

12-06-2008, 15:35	#5
Mark Screaming Orgasm Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Newbury Posts: 15,194	The problem isn't whether SDHC works (it does), it's whether the card will be fast enough to compete with my existing SD cards (none of the three SDHC cards I already have are fast enough, but none of them are Sandisk).

21-06-2008, 21:21	#6
Mark Screaming Orgasm Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Newbury Posts: 15,194	It works. \o/ Moral of this story - if you want a fast SD or SDHC card, avoid the chaff.